The Giver of Stars

The first two days of Margery’s trial don’t bode well. The Pack Horse Library remains closed during the proceedings, and though the girls arrive early to the courthouse as a show of strength, the verdict seems all but assured. Mr. Van Cleve has obvious influence with the sheriff, and Margery’s own appearance in court makes her look scary and guilty. The prosecution paints a picture of her as a crazed, dangerous murderer that’s a menace to any God-fearing society.

During the first day’s proceedings, Alice rushes outside and throws up. In comforting Alice, Kathleen mentions how ugly the town has become in siding against Margery. These words echo something Margery once told Alice: “There is always a way out of a situation. Might be ugly” (347). Alice takes heart at the remembrance. The trial drags on, with the prosecution calling forth doctors and character witnesses against Margery.

One day after the proceedings, the librarians return to the library, despondent. Alice goes to retrieve liquor to lighten the mood and runs into Bennett. They chat briefly, and he mentions that the prosecution never questioned McCullough’s daughters. He also reveals that he’s making changes to the mines to improve safety, including fixing the slurries.